PYS 1.42–43: Grobe Samāpatti
PYS 1.42–43: Grobe Samāpatti

Yogaśāstra 1.42–43: Savitarkā and Nirvitarkā

In savitarkā, word, object, and cognition are mixed. When the corresponding memories are purified, only the gross object appears in nirvitarkā.

Dr. Ronald Steiner Dr. Ronald Steiner Laura von Ostrowski Laura von Ostrowski
Patañjali Yoga Sūtra 1.42
तत्र शब्दार्थज्ञानविकल्पैः संकीर्णा सवितर्का समापत्तिः ||42||
tatra śabdārtha-jñāna-vikalpaiḥ saṃkīrṇā savitarkā samāpattiḥ ||42|| Analysis ▾ Analysis ▴
tatra
adverb
among these
śabda
dvandva-compound
substantive masculine
word
artha
dvandva-compound
substantive masculine
object
jñāna
tatpuruṣa-compound genitive
substantive neuter
cognition
vikalpaiḥ
instrumental case plural
substantive masculine
by conceptual constructions
saṃkīrṇā
nominative singular feminine
adjective
mixed
savitarkā
nominative singular feminine
adjective
with gross deliberation
samāpattiḥ
nominative singular
substantive feminine
Samāpatti
Among these (tatra), [the Samāpatti] mixed (saṃkīrṇā | nom sg f) with conceptual constructions of word, object and cognition (śabdārtha-jñāna-vikalpaiḥ | ins pl) [is] Samāpatti with gross deliberation (savitarkā samāpattiḥ | nom sg).
Dr. Ronald Steiner - 2026 - historically literal
In an encounter, distinguish the name, what you directly perceive, and what you already know about it. These three layers can work together without silently merging.
Dr. Ronald Steiner - 2026 - modern transfer

In savitarkā-samāpatti, word, object, and cognition are mixed. The Bhāṣya illustrates this with the word “cow,” the animal it denotes, and the cognition “cow”: although they belong to distinct domains, they are apprehended without differentiation. When memory of linguistic convention is purified, samādhi-prajñā is free from concepts derived from tradition and inference, and the object appears solely in its own form, there is nirvitarkā-samāpatti. The Bhāṣya calls it supreme perception and the basis of tradition and inference, while remaining unmixed with them.

Yoga Śāstra Vyāsa-Bhāṣya
This (change of the mind into the likeness of what is pondered) when mixed up of the fancy of the ‘Word’ the ‘Meaning’ and the ‘Knowledge’ is (technically termed) the ‘Argumentative’.
James R. Ballantyne - 1852
The argumentative condition is that which is mixed with the modification of words, meaning and understanding (or idea.)
Ganganatha Jha - 1907
Ist diese (samāpatti) noch behaftet mit Unsicherheit in betreff der Erkenntnis der Wortbedeutungen, so heißt sie eine zweifelbehaftete (savitarkā).
Paul Deussen - 1908
Of [these balanced-states] the state-balanced with deliberation is confused by reason of predicate-relations between words and intended-objects and ideas.
James Haughton Woods - 1914
Patañjali Yoga Sūtra 1.43
स्मृतिपरिशुद्धौ स्वरूपशून्येवार्थमात्रनिर्भासा निर्वितर्का ||43||
smṛti-pariśuddhau svarūpa-śūnyevārthamātra-nirbhāsā nirvitarkā ||43|| Analysis ▾ Analysis ▴
smṛti
tatpuruṣa-compound genitive
substantive feminine
of memory
pariśuddhau
lokative absolutus singular
substantive feminine
upon complete purification
svarūpa
tatpuruṣa-compound instrumental case
substantive neuter
of its own form
śūnyā
nominative singular feminine
adjective
empty
iva
particle
as if
arthamātra
upapada-compound
substantive neuter
the object alone
nirbhāsā
nominative singular feminine
adjective
causing to shine forth
nirvitarkā
nominative singular feminine
adjective
without gross deliberation
Upon complete purification of memory (smṛti-pariśuddhau | loc absl sg), [the Samāpatti is] without gross deliberation (nirvitarkā | nom sg f): as if (iva) empty of its own form (svarūpa-śūnyā | nom sg f) and causing the object alone to shine forth (artha-mātra-nirbhāsā | nom sg f).
Dr. Ronald Steiner - 2026 - historically literal
For a few breaths, meet a familiar object as though for the first time. Let names and preconceptions soften so that colour, form, sound, or touch can appear freshly.
Dr. Ronald Steiner - 2026 - modern transfer

In nirvitarkā-samāpatti, memory of verbal convention and of knowledge from tradition and inference has been purified. Prajñā, colored by the apprehended object, relinquishes as it were its own cognitive form and appears solely as that object. The Bhāṣya adds an ontological defense of this gross object: things such as a cow or pot are real wholes (avayavin) apprehended as unities, not merely unreal heaps of atoms. Otherwise nirvitarkā-samāpatti would have no object and nearly all ordinary cognition would be false.

Yoga Śāstra Vyāsa-Bhāṣya
On the clearing off the memory (of the word and the sense attached to it by convention), the (Mental) Display only of the thing itself as if of something indefinitive (and no Longer referred to any term - no longer regarded as being what is meant by the word ‘Cow’ or what is Meant by the word ‘horse’ etc.). This (affection of the mind which no longer reflects A mixed object of thought) is that which is called technically the ‘Non-Argumentative’.
James R. Ballantyne - 1852
The non-argumentative is that in which, on the dissolution of memory, the meaning (or object,) alone, is apparent, and which appears as if devoid of its own identity.
Ganganatha Jha - 1907
Sie heißt eine zweifelfreie (nirvitarkā), wenn sie, von den [aus einer früheren Geburt stammenden] Erinnerungen gereinigt und gleichsam der eigenen Natur ledig, nur das Objekt widerspiegelt.
Paul Deussen - 1908
When the memory is quite purified, [that balanced-state] which is, as it were, empty of itself and which brightens [into conscious knowledge] as the intended-object and nothing more is super-deliberative.
James Haughton Woods - 1914

Continue with AYI Free

Illustrations: AI-generated.

Editor

Dr. Ronald Steiner

From Ulm

The "Yoga Doc" - Dr. Ronald Steiner is the founder of the AYI method. This method links traditional Ashtanga Yoga with innovative Yogatherapy and living Philosophy. This forms a practice that is personal for each and... more ›

Laura von Ostrowski

Ich bin 2004 das erste Mal mit Yoga in Berührung gekommen und habe seitdem unendlich viele Facetten kennengelernt. Einerseits die vielfältigen praktischen Seiten von Yoga - in Form verschiedener Ausbildungen (500 h... more ›

Messages and ratings
1 messages Ø

Please log in to write a message. Go to login